I think that having a GIT branch identical to the snapshot would be useful when investigating problems reported in the snapshot, particularly if master becomes less stable than now.

Currently, the unstable version is publicly known and the name is used in the Download section of the web site. I have been telling people to download the "unstable" version for several months. If we change the names, we will need to be very explicit on the web site in order to avoid useless queries.

Best

Michel


On 09/19/2011 02:08 PM, Stéphane Adjemian wrote:
I agree with Sébastien.

A "testing"-snapshot version would be enough if we distribute the windows binaries *and* the sources... Because the idea is
not to commit directly in the "testing" branch but to automatically cherry-pick (in testing) commits from master.

Best,
Stéphane.

Sébastien Villemot <sebastien.villemot@ens.fr> writes:

Michel Juillard <michel.juillard@mjui.fr> writes:

It is very urgent to put in place the testing version that we talked
about. I have referred several people to the unstable version for
things that I fixed over the Summer and we can't having it broken over
long periods of time (more than one day, I would say)

In fact, intstead of having stable, (new) testing, unstable, I would
suggest that we have stable, unstable (that we try to keep in workable
state), (new) experimental which is not supposed to be entirely
working. The names will be a bit misleading but it will avoid to have
to inform people who download unstable to have to download testing
instead.
Personally I prefer the name "testing", it corresponds more to the
reality.

However, I realize that if we want to implement this "testing" version
only for users who download the snapshot (and not for those who use
git), there is no need to create a new branch. I could just modify my
snapshot building script so that a new snapshot is only created if all
tests pass in the testsuite. The lastest snapshot available for download
would therefore correspond to the last working state of the git. From
the point of view of users who download the snapshot, this is
"observationally equivalent" to having a testing branch.

      
_______________________________________________ Dev mailing list Dev@dynare.org https://www.dynare.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dev